Latest News

Home / Uncategorized / “my” versus. “mine” inside the several manager possessive

“my” versus. “mine” inside the several manager possessive

“my” versus. “mine” inside the several manager possessive

“We therefore appreciate your getting my and you may Gregg’s guy to school now.” – however, I will suggest “our boy” or perhaps the kid’s identity would-be more natural than “my and Gregg’s man”?

When i agree with Warsaw Have a tendency to, would it remain grammatically correct to make use of “mine” in such a case, if you believe from “mine” as dealing with “my personal guy”? That is, can you imagine the first sentence is actually so it?:

– Okay, however, In my opinion Gregg’s man should come first in one to case making clear exactly what “mine” try writing on:

In fact, it is not precise throughout the new if or not we have been talking regarding the several people. If it’s that, in addition to presenter however desires discuss both themself and you can Gregg, i quickly consider “Gregg’s and you can my son” was more natural than “My personal and you will Gregg’s son”. Assuming there are 2 – I’d favor “Gregg’s and you may my loved ones”, I think.

Hi porsche, I’m nevertheless not very yes

– I know it isn’t everything expected, nevertheless the more In my opinion about it, the less cause I pick to refer sometimes Gregg or myself; each other understands whose child try on it. If we present our girl in order to some one I really don’t consider i usually say, “This will be Gregg’s and my girl”, but both “This is exactly our girl” otherwise “This might be my personal daughter”. Subsequently, I think we’d be much more planning to say “my personal son” otherwise “my child” than simply “my kid”, wouldn’t i? Or as i said before, just have fun with its identity:

Towards the analogy offered from the unique matter, my personal is right and you can mine grammatically impossible – others is design.

– We agree that everything say is the means to fix the fresh brand spanking new question, nevertheless the other individuals is not only on layout, it’s about group of sheer. I recently don’t believe you to definitely “my personal and you may Gregg’s child” was absolute English. It will not sound in my experience such as for instance something a local presenter manage say.

Often, I trust almost all you said, except for some thing

You said that the initial phrase is not too clear. We differ. The type help with yet provides a very specific definition:

can only just mean exactly the same thing. A few would state this might be ungrammatical, having “my” future first, in case not ungrammatical, it’s at least sensed rude from the most of the. So it pronoun shift is entirely unacceptable, even yet in informal speech. For people who chat in this way, everyone, “educated” or not, often believe you will be an early teenager which cannot lay out their smartphone.

can also merely indicate Greg enjoys a kid, you have a different sort of kid, and you can anybody grabbed one another children to school. While this and matical, it is still impolite. Understand the remark above from the “my”.

Note, evey single one among these systems is very unambiguous. Perhaps are grammatical, however are to be avoided for explanations said.

Past, Have a tendency to, your own feedback concerning the have to speak about Greg is extremely well pulled. Particularly for instances when Greg along with a kid along with her, it could be extremely unlikely to refer Greg whatsoever (that makes it also better one “mine” meaans one or two different children). Earliest, because of the discussing Greg, it is about designed that he’s maybe not in fact establish. If it are the case, why should he additionally be mentioned? You would just say

We entirely agree totally that most of the sentences you considering is unambiguous, however, they might be every results of our interpretation of the unique phrase. Okay, since the sbee then requires whether or not it are going to be ‘my’, he does make it clear, in case i do the original phrase because really stands as opposed to that opinion, i then nevertheless found it not sure. I thinkl that is what We intended.

Leave a Comment